ACE Your Poetry Commentary...EVERY TIME!

Main Ideas / Concepts / Lessons

• Writing poetry commentary for essays is difficult, but it’s important because strong commentary helps you score well in high school and college poetry essays.
• The video is part of a poetry essay series focused on how to write poetry analysis throughout AP Lit and beyond.
• The speaker frames the task as finishing a body paragraph:
  • You’ve already done (1) a topic sentence and (2) integrated evidence.
  • To earn higher scores, you still need commentary explaining how the evidence supports the claim.
• Key goal: write at least three sentences of focused, logical commentary tied directly to the claim in the topic sentence.
• The video emphasizes:
  • Causal/logical reasoning language
  • Commentary stems (transitional words and “because/therefore” logic) to move from lower rubric performance to higher performance.

---

Methodology / Instruction List

Step 1: Use what you already have (topic sentence + evidence)

Confirm your body paragraph already includes:

• A topic sentence with a clear claim.
• Integrated textual evidence (quote/details inserted smoothly).

---

Step 2: Write commentary that explains evidence-to-claim connections

For your commentary, you must explain:

• How the evidence proves the claim in your topic sentence.

The speaker’s example scenario includes:

• Evidence involving a frame narrative and curta / “saura” (likely referring to césura / line breaks or a similar poetic break) that symbolizes:
  • The shattered state of a monument/statue
  • A break in time between the statue’s inception and the traveler’s viewing

---

Step 3: Use a 3+ sentence commentary template (minimum 3 sentences)

This template is designed to force logical, consistent commentary—especially for AP Lit rubric scoring.

Sentence 1

• Start by paraphrasing the evidence you just used.
  • Use an -ing verb (e.g., describing, mentioning, constructing, highlighting) to show what the author is doing.
• Connect that evidence to the claim from your topic sentence.
• Don’t stop after the connection—add “because” to explain reasoning.

Example structure (conceptual): “_ [paraphrased evidence] highlights [claim] because __ [reasoning/logic].”

Sentence 2

• Start with a consequence or logical progression transition such as:
  • “Consequently,” (or similar)
• Explain the outcome/impact of the first observation.

Example concept from the video: Because the narrative shifts from the original speaker to a traveler/passerby, it pushes the plot into the past, separating present-viewer time from earlier time.

Sentence 3

• Start with a logical transition like:
  • “Thus,”
• Include the second required element referenced in the topic sentence/evidence (the speaker connects “saura” to fragmentation).
• Add “due to the fact that” to force reasoning clarity.

Example structure (conceptual): “Thus, _ [how the second element functions] represent/reflect [claim] due to the fact that __ [explanation].”

---

Step 4: Optional expansion (more cause/effect + transitions)

If you want more depth than the minimum, add further sentences using:

• Furthermore
• However
• Therefore
• In addition

The speaker’s example expansions include:

• Pauses by speakers highlight passing time and separation of observers across history.
• Visual interruptions/line fragmentation create a comparative sensory experience with what the unnamed narrator describes.

---

Step 5: General advice about using the stems

• The speaker acknowledges a concern about repetition.
• The response: you’ll still use your own reasoning between the stems, so it won’t feel generic.
• The goal is higher scoring because commentary becomes more consistently logical.

---

Speakers / Sources Featured (as mentioned)

• Tim Frusz (host/teacher; referenced in a line: “I’m Tim frus…from the Garden of English”)
• Miss Jackson (AP teacher shout-out: AP Lit students at San Marcos High School)
• AP Lit students at San Marcos High School (group mentioned; not individually named)
• AP Lit rubric / AP Literature poetry commentary rubric (referenced as a scoring system)
• The Garden of English (channel/creator referenced as the source of materials)