Video summary
POWERLINE AV1300 vs AV600 - Bad results! Best Review on Youtube - Extensive testing
Main summary
Key takeaways
Product(s) reviewed
- TP-Link Powerline AV600 (AV-600 kit) vs TP-Link Powerline AV1300 (AV-1300 kit) using home electrical wiring, compared across:
- distance
- circuits/switchboards
- interference
Main features mentioned
-
Powerline networking setup: Plug one unit near the router using Ethernet, then plug other units into wall sockets to distribute internet through the home’s wiring.
-
AV-600 (base model): Mentioned as having fewer outlets, implying simpler hardware (generally cheaper).
-
AV-1300 (base model): Includes 2.4 GHz and 5 GHz Wi‑Fi for more capable wireless performance.
-
Compatibility/mixing: AV-1300 can be paired with AV-600 units using pairing buttons.
-
Performance is highly dependent on:
- distance from the emitter (base unit)
- whether wiring crosses circuit breakers / switchboards
- electrical-line interference from appliances on the same circuit
Key test results / numerical values (as stated)
Baseline comparisons (very close, ~10 feet)
- Router baseline (2.4 GHz):
- Download speeds around 34–43 Mbps (values included ~34 and ~43).
- AV-600 at ~10 ft:
- Download speeds around 41–42 Mbps
- Described as little/no loss vs router (sometimes even “gains,” though fluctuating).
- AV-1300 at 2.4 GHz:
- Around 40–45 Mbps (examples mentioned include ~41, then “massive jump” to ~36–44, “up to ~45”).
- AV-1300 at 5 GHz:
- Much higher, about ~137 Mbps download (contrasted with ~40 Mbps on 2.4 GHz).
Mixing brands/models (AV-1300 base with AV-600 receiver)
- Pairing was described as instant via pairing buttons.
- Mixed setup performed better than using two AV-600 units together, with the AV-1300 base pushing a stronger signal.
Distance + circuit impact
- ~25 ft, passing through one switchboard (AV-1300 kit, 5 GHz):
- Roughly 140 Mbps → ~90–94 Mbps
- Stated as about a 30–40% loss.
- ~30 ft, AV-1300 5 GHz:
- Download about ~58–50 Mbps (“about half” speed loss)
- Upload around ~16 Mbps mentioned.
- ~60 ft, AV-1300 5 GHz:
- Download falls to roughly ~13–14 Mbps
- Described as about four times lower than the earlier ~140 result, but still “works.”
- One-room comparison (AV-1300 base vs AV-600 paired receivers):
- AV-1300 kit through one switchboard: about ~92–94 Mbps
- AV-600 paired with AV-1300 base: sometimes around ~54 Mbps (fluctuating due to interference)
Interference tests (major negative finding)
When multiple appliances are on the same electrical line:
- Baseline/initial download: ~46 Mbps
- Adding a lamp: drops to about ~25–27 Mbps
- Adding TV (with lamp also on): further losses, down into the low 20s
- ~21–24 Mbps mentioned
- When the TV is switched on, the reviewer emphasizes the drop is “major.”
- With an AV-600 receiver, interference became so bad it:
- resulted in loss of connection altogether (“no internet,” “beeping”)
- required re-pairing / unplug-replugging
- Trying via an extension (different socket arrangement) did not fix interference; results still failed similarly.
Pros (as presented in the video)
- Can deliver strong speeds, especially AV-1300 + 5 GHz close to the unit.
- AV-1300 base can improve performance of AV-600 receivers when paired.
- Can be reasonably stable in a “proper environment” (fewer appliances on the same circuit).
- Under good conditions, speeds can be comparable to (or not far from) router Wi‑Fi.
- Mix-and-match pairing works (AV-1300 with AV-600) and is easy.
Cons (as presented in the video)
-
Severe interference sensitivity: Multiple appliances on the same electrical line can cause dramatic speed drops and even loss of connectivity, particularly harming AV-600.
-
Speed drops with distance and when crossing switchboards/circuit breakers.
- Highly volatile performance (values may change rapidly), especially over Wi‑Fi radios.
- If many devices/appliances share the same circuit, the system may become unusable.
Comparisons made
-
AV-600 vs router: AV-600 near emitter: ~41–42 Mbps vs router ~34–43 Mbps (often “no loss” in the close test).
-
AV-1300 vs AV-600: AV-1300 generally has a higher ceiling, especially on 5 GHz (up to ~137 Mbps in the close test).
-
AV-1300 5 GHz vs 2.4 GHz: Reviewer highlights a huge difference, with 5 GHz far faster.
-
AV-1300 base + AV-600 receiver vs AV-600 + AV-600: Described as better with AV-1300 as the base.
-
Practical guidance:
- If crossing switchboards, AV-1300 can be better.
- If not, AV-600 may be acceptable since speeds can converge in some scenarios.
Overall user experience notes
- Setup is straightforward (Ethernet from router to base).
- Connectivity can be stable in the right conditions.
- In high-interference rooms, it becomes unreliable, including:
- repeated unplug/replug
- re-pairing
- “no internet” despite sync
- The reviewer claims AV-600 especially struggles in interference-heavy scenarios.
Unique points mentioned (consolidated)
- Powerline kits require router Ethernet and distribute internet via existing wiring.
- AV-600 base has fewer outlets; AV-1300 has more (3 outlets mentioned).
- Reviewer’s units generally worked for about one year, with occasional stops fixed by restarting powerline devices.
- Best performance when units are on the same electrical circuit; crossing breakers/switchboards reduces speed.
- Major negative issue: interference from appliances on the same line can cause unusable speeds or disconnects.
- Close-range speed tests show AV-600 and AV-1300 (2.4 GHz) near-router performance.
- AV-1300 on 5 GHz provides the biggest improvements (up to about ~137 Mbps).
- Mixing models is possible and works well; AV-1300 base boosts AV-600 performance.
- Distance causes speed loss (about half around ~30 ft; very low around ~60 ft but still functioning).
- Extension-socket test did not alleviate interference.
- Recommendation depends on room/appliance count: avoid offices/rooms with many electronics on the same circuit.
Speakers / multiple perspectives
- One speaker (“John”) delivered the entire review and all test conclusions.
Verdict / recommendation (concise)
- Buy AV-1300 if you want maximum speed (especially 5 GHz) and your home/room has low appliance interference and reasonable electrical conditions.
- Avoid powerline in rooms/circuits with many appliances (TVs, lamps, computers, etc.), because the reviewer observed dramatic interference and sometimes complete loss of connection.
- In moderate setups (same circuit / crossing only one switchboard), AV-600 may be a better value since speeds can be similar to AV-1300 in those cases.