Record Label Drops Band Because of "Ugly Opinions" UGH...

Summary

The presenter discusses Castle Face Records’ decision to drop Austin psychedelic/alternative band Dream Machine after an interview in which band members Matthew and Doris Melton expressed views critical of immigration policy, feminism, “safe spaces,” and political correctness. The presenter says the label also tried to remove the band’s album from circulation and planned to donate any proceeds it received to charity.

He argues that listeners need not agree with the band, but that its political opinions are not a fair reason to cut off its access to a label or livelihood. He criticizes what he sees as a climate in which artists and creators feel pressured to soften their views for fear of losing support, work, or an audience. He compares the situation with controversies involving PewDiePie and YouTube creators affected by advertiser concerns.

The presenter also says musicians should consider whether political commentary belongs alongside their music, since it may alienate some listeners. Still, he argues that people can separate art from the artist, and that Dream Machine should not be equated with artists accused or convicted of serious misconduct. He acknowledges that a record label can make its own business decisions, but says those decisions—and the label’s actions—can also be criticized. Ultimately, he argues that consumers, rather than a label, should decide whether to support the band.

Presenters and Contributors

• RanterInShades — presenter and commentator
• Matthew and Doris Melton — Dream Machine members whose interview comments are discussed and quoted