Summary of "КАК СОЗДАТЬ ПРИКЛЮЧЕНИЕ-ДЕТЕКТИВ | ПРАВИЛО ТРЕХ УЛИК"

Summary of “КАК СОЗДАТЬ ПРИКЛЮЧЕНИЕ-ДЕТЕКТИВ | ПРАВИЛО ТРЕХ УЛИК”

This video from the Spell Check channel offers advice to game masters (GMs) on designing detective-style adventure plots that involve riddles and mysteries. The main focus is on making puzzles accessible and engaging for players, who do not have the omniscient perspective of the GM. The presenter introduces the “Rule of Three Clues” as a core methodology for creating effective mystery plots.

Main Ideas and Concepts

Player Perspective vs. GM Perspective

GMs often know the entire mystery solution, but players do not. This difference can cause players to miss or misunderstand clues, leading to frustration or boredom.

Rule of Three Clues

For every conclusion or piece of information players need to solve the mystery, provide at least three different clues or ways to discover it. - Players will likely miss or ignore some clues, so multiple clues increase the chances they will find at least one. - If players find all three clues, it confirms their deductions and enriches the story.

Example Case Study

A mystery involving several murdered girls in a village, with a werewolf as the killer. The players must discover: 1. Who or what the killer is (werewolf) 2. The killer’s motive (shared lover) 3. The location related to the crime (butcher’s shop)

For each of these conclusions, three clues are provided, such as: - Werewolf: Traces of wolf-to-human footprints, wounds from large claws, or silver bullets. - Motive: Love letters, diary entries, or images linking victims to the same person. - Location: A broken meat box, a note about meeting at the butcher’s, or diary mentions.

Multiple Solutions and Fail-safes

Each riddle or obstacle should have multiple solutions or ways to progress.
If a skill check is required (e.g., finding a secret door), provide alternatives like interrogating NPCs, finding notes, or triggering events that reveal the solution.
This prevents the story from stalling if players fail a check or miss a clue.

Backup Plans for Dead Ends

Players sometimes misinterpret clues or ignore them, heading off track.
The GM should have backup events to reorient players, such as:
- New victims or incidents that provide fresh clues.
- Direct villain encounters revealing critical information.
Avoid overly deceptive clues that might mislead players into ignoring real evidence.

Additional Benefits of Multiple Clues

Adds depth and detail to the story and setting (e.g., a secret door gains “history” through multiple clues).
Encourages player creativity and engagement.
Helps the GM manage pacing and player progress without forcing a single path.

Practical Advice for GMs

Write down all clues, evidence, and plot details to avoid forgetting them during play.
Be flexible and encourage players to come up with their own solutions.
Use clues as safety nets rather than strict requirements.
Plan several paths to success and provide insurance against player failure.

Methodology / Instructions (Rule of Three Clues)

For every key conclusion or piece of information: - Provide three distinct clues or ways for players to discover it. - Ensure clues vary in type (e.g., physical evidence, NPC testimony, written notes). - Design multiple solutions to obstacles (not just one skill check). - Prepare backup events to redirect players if they reach a dead end. - Avoid overly misleading clues that might derail the investigation. - Document all clues and plot points carefully. - Encourage player creativity and alternative approaches.

Speakers / Sources Featured

Main Speaker: Unnamed presenter from the Spell Check YouTube channel
Referenced Source: Sherlock Holmes (specifically the quote and reasoning from A Study in Scarlet) used to illustrate the use of multiple clues to solve a mystery.

In essence, the video teaches GMs to design detective adventures that are player-friendly, robust, and rich in detail by using the “Rule of Three Clues” to ensure players have multiple opportunities to uncover each piece of the mystery, thus maintaining engagement and narrative flow.