Summary of "The Great Metals Crash of 2026: What 140 Years of Data Predicts Happens Next . This may surprise!"

The Great Metals Crash of Jan 30, 2026 — summary (Clive Thompson)

Date / presenter

Video recorded Jan 31, 2026 by Clive Thompson.

Assets, instruments and tickers mentioned

Commodities: gold, silver, platinum, palladium (spot and futures).
ETFs / funds: iShares Silver Trust (SLV); ProShares Ultra Silver Fund (leveraged).
Stocks / sectors: mining stocks (example: Kerr Mining).
Crypto: Bitcoin.
Indices / benchmarks: Dow Jones Industrial Average, S&P 500, NASDAQ, DXY (US Dollar Index).
Instruments / mechanics: futures, spot, CFDs (contracts for difference), margin trading, stop‑loss orders.
Venue: Shanghai futures market.
Banks / analysts referenced: Deutsche Bank, Société Générale, Citi (price targets mentioned).

What happened — key numbers & timeline

Context (2025–early 2026) - 2025 rally: gold +~66% in 2025; silver +~135% in 2025. - Pre‑crash extremes cited: gold near ~$5,600; silver passed ~$120.

Crash day: Friday, Jan 30, 2026 (“Smackdown Friday”) - Gold (spot): fell ~8.99% to about $4,893.59 (futures fell more — speaker cited ~11.4% and futures finishing ~ $150 below spot in places). - Silver (spot): fell ~26.44% in one day (speaker repeatedly emphasized ~26%); some near‑dated futures down ~$31–$36 (~31% on some contracts). - Platinum: down ~17.2% to ~2,150. - Palladium: down ~16.25% to ~1,682 (Shanghai futures down ~16% or ~$21). - SLV (iShares Silver Trust): down ~31% (speaker warned about NAV distortions during fast moves). - ProShares Ultra Silver Fund (leveraged): cratered by >62%. - Mining stocks: heavy falls (example: Kerr Mining down ~17%; many miners worse). - Broader equities: Dow and S&P down ~0.4%; NASDAQ down ~0.9%. - Bitcoin: down ~2% to ~$81,000 on Friday; traded ~ $78,000 over the weekend.

Immediate market drivers cited

Policy / political catalyst:
- President Trump announced nomination of Kevin Walsh to be Fed Chair.
- Initial market interpretation: Walsh seen as a potential “sound‑money” (hawkish) pick because of his 2011 resignation. Thompson argues Walsh’s more recent comments could be dovish and align with Trump’s push for lower rates.
Dollar reaction:
- DXY rallied roughly +1% on the announcement (stronger dollar makes dollar‑priced commodities more expensive for international buyers).
Microstructure / liquidity cascade:
- Large, crowded parabolic long positions — many on margin or via CFDs/leveraged ETFs — with tight stop‑losses.
- Stop‑loss cascade: a triggered stop can force sales that hit other stops, creating a downward spiral.
- Traders/shorts could sell into stops knowing they can buy back cheaper, amplifying the move.
- Futures and leveraged products amplified losses and created liquidity dislocations (futures moved more than spot).

Historical analysis — methodology

Data sets:
- Dow Jones single‑day crashes: analysis back to 1885 (~130 years, ~38,000 data points).
- Gold & silver daily data: back to ~Aug 2000 (~26 years, ~6,300 data points).
Event definition:
- Identified single trading days where an asset fell by ≥5% (also examined ≥10%, ≥15%, ≥20%).
Horizons analyzed:
- Subsequent returns measured at 7, 30, 91, 182 and 365 days after each ≥5% single‑day drop.
Statistical outputs:
- Frequency counts (how many up vs down after X days), average returns for up occasions, average returns including down occasions, and histograms of outcome distributions.

Historical results — headline findings & key statistics

Dow Jones (≥5% single‑day drops — ~85 events since 1885) - After a 5%+ day, the market was roughly twice as likely to be higher than lower across most horizons. - One‑year outcome: ~62 occasions higher vs ~23 occasions lower (≈2:1 odds up vs down). - Average one‑year return after a 5% drop (including ups & downs): ~ +22% (best +138%, worst ≈ −48%). - When the market went up after such a drop, average rise was large (~+38%).

Gold (≥5% single‑day drops since 2000) - Rare: about 10 such single‑day crashes in the sample. - One year after a 5% gold crash: more often higher than lower (speaker cited ~6 up vs 2 down examples). - Average one‑year return after a crash was modestly positive (speaker cited figures in the range of roughly +9–14% when including losses; narration varied).

Silver (≥5% single‑day drops since 2000) - Much more volatile: ~96 instances of ≥5% single‑day drops. - One‑year outcome: up 56 times and down 32 times (~64% of the time up one year later). - Average gain on the up occasions: ~+38% (recoveries can be strong).

Correlation between metal crashes and stock market - Weak correlation: precious‑metal crashes are not a reliable predictor of stock‑market collapse. - On days gold crashed ≥5%, the Dow fell only ~60% of the time (rose ~40%). - On days silver crashed ≥5%, the Dow fell ~57% vs rose ~43%.

Analyst targets / macro views referenced

Pre‑crash analyst forecasts (context):
- Deutsche Bank and Société Générale reportedly had gold targets near $6,000 for 2026.
- Citi reportedly had silver near $150.
Presenter’s view:
- Fundamentals cited in favor of metals (geopolitical risk, reserve diversification away from USD) remain relevant.
- Much depends on interpretation of Kevin Walsh’s likely stance (hawkish vs dovish).

Risks, cautions & practical guidance (speaker)

Leveraged products magnify losses: example — ProShares Ultra Silver lost >62% in a single day.
CFDs and margin accounts often have automatic tight stop‑losses that amplify moves.
ETFs can trade away from NAV during fast moves — quoted ETF prices may misrepresent underlying NAV movements.
Physical market spreads widen: coin shop bid/ask spreads can blow out during dislocations; buying/selling physical metal immediately can be costly.
Behavioral advice:
- Don’t rush to buy or sell amid the immediate turmoil; spreads are wide and liquidity poor.
- If trading, use very small sizes to test the market.
- Consider holding — Thompson said he is “sitting on hands.”
Disclosure from presenter:

“This is not investment advice.”

Conclusions & probabilities given

Historically, violent single‑day crashes in stocks or precious metals have frequently preceded strong rebounds; longer holding horizons increase the probability of positive returns.
For silver specifically, historical odds favor recovery (roughly 2:1 in favor of being higher one year later).
Short term: expect elevated volatility in the coming days/weeks as markets re‑price policy news (Kevin Walsh nomination) and liquidity stabilizes.
Presenter’s personal view: odds favor recovery over time, especially if the Fed ends up dovish (which he expects), but the outcome is uncertain.