Summary of "Lezione online per studenti - C. Giorda: Perchè il nozionismo ha ucciso la geografia"
Summary of the Video:
Lezione online per studenti - C. Giorda: Perchè il nozionismo ha ucciso la geografia
Main Ideas and Concepts
-
Critique of Notionalism in Geography Education Notionalism refers to the rote memorization of disconnected facts (e.g., lists of provinces, rivers, or agricultural products like sugar beet) without meaningful context or understanding. This approach “kills” geography by making it boring and irrelevant, leading to a loss of passion and interest among students. Despite widespread agreement that notionalism is ineffective, it persists in textbooks and school practices.
-
The Importance of Meaningful Connections Knowledge should be connected to real-life contexts, relationships, and scales (local, regional, global). For example, instead of memorizing that sugar beet is grown in a region, teaching should explore what sugar beet is used for, how it relates to everyday life (e.g., sugar in food), the landscape it creates, and its economic and geopolitical significance. Geography should be taught as a complex, systemic science studying the interaction between humans and the environment, culture, economy, politics, and natural systems.
-
Reconsidering the Nature-Anthropic Divide Traditional exercises that separate “natural” from “human-made” elements often reinforce a false dualism between man and nature. Instead, a three-level classification is proposed to better understand human impact on nature:
- Level 1: Original nature (unaltered by humans, e.g., sun, clouds)
- Level 2: Transformed nature (natural elements altered by human activity but still recognizable, e.g., cultivated fields, dirt roads, urban parks)
- Level 3: Highly transformed nature (completely altered, e.g., cities, asphalt roads, buildings)
This model helps students grasp the co-evolution and interdependence of humans and natural environments.
-
Landscape as a Product of Human-Nature Interaction Landscapes reflect the degree of human transformation and adaptation to the environment. Understanding landscapes requires interpreting these layers and recognizing the cultural and ecological diversity they embody. Even urban environments are composed of transformed natural materials, emphasizing the inseparability of humans and nature.
-
Problems with Traditional Geographic Concepts and Exercises Examples such as memorizing right and left tributaries of rivers or classifying hills by altitude without considering morphology are criticized as meaningless and disengaging. Such exercises do not connect with students’ lived experiences or stimulate curiosity.
-
Geography as an Experiential and Emotional Discipline Geography should be taught through exploration, observation, and emotional engagement with places. Encouraging wonder, curiosity, and personal connection to landscapes helps students internalize geographic knowledge meaningfully. The metaphor of geography as a “liquid road” between humans and the earth (from Homer) highlights its dynamic, relational nature.
-
Recommendations for Geography Textbooks and Teaching Textbooks should:
- Stimulate curiosity and emotions, not just present facts.
- Use high-quality, meaningful images that connect with the text and encourage reflection.
- Have a coherent structure that builds conceptual understanding progressively rather than isolated chapters.
Teaching should focus on building conceptual foundations that allow students to understand and analyze geographical phenomena critically.
-
Geographical Education and Sustainable Development Understanding the interconnectedness of nature, society, and economy is fundamental to addressing sustainability challenges. Geography education must promote awareness of human impact on the environment and the necessity of caring for the planet.
-
Final Metaphor and Vision The video concludes with a metaphor inspired by the artist Fontana: geography “cuts through” the surface to reveal hidden layers beneath the visible world, inviting imagination, curiosity, and deeper understanding. Geography education should maintain three moments: emotional engagement, conceptual understanding, and analytical synthesis.
Methodology / Instructions for Teaching Geography
- Avoid rote memorization of isolated facts (notionalism).
- Connect knowledge to students’ everyday lives and experiences:
- Explain the uses and significance of geographic elements (e.g., agricultural products, landscapes).
- Relate local phenomena to broader scales and global contexts.
- Use the three-level classification to teach about human-environment interaction:
- Level 1: Original nature (unaltered elements).
- Level 2: Partially transformed nature (recognizable but altered).
- Level 3: Highly transformed nature (urbanized, constructed environments).
- Design exercises that promote understanding of relationships and co-evolution rather than separation:
- Encourage students to observe and interpret landscapes rather than memorize lists.
- Use photographs and real-world examples to illustrate these categories.
- Incorporate emotional and experiential learning:
- Foster curiosity and wonder about places.
- Encourage exploration, observation, and personal connection to geographic space.
- Select textbooks and materials that:
- Stimulate interest and reflection through quality images and integrated texts.
- Are structured to build conceptual understanding progressively.
- Emphasize the systemic nature of geography:
- Teach the earth system as an integrated whole (lithosphere, atmosphere, biosphere, including humans as part of the biosphere).
- Highlight the interdependence of natural and human systems.
- Use metaphor and narrative to make geography meaningful:
- For example, trace the journey of a tomato from origin to table to connect nature, culture, economy, and history.
- Encourage critical thinking about traditional geographic categories and challenge misleading exercises.
- Promote awareness of sustainability and the human impact on the planet as core geographic themes.
Speakers / Sources Featured
- Cristiano Giorda – Associate Professor of Geography at the University of Turin; experienced teacher and author; member of the Italian Association of Geography Teachers.
- Italian Association of Geography Teachers (Associazione Italiana Insegnanti di Geografia) – Collaborator in the webinar.
- Lei Sheridan Publishing Houses – Promoter of the distance learning program hosting the webinar.
- Eric Dalle Belle – French geographer quoted regarding the spirit of geographical discovery.
- Other references:
- Homer (metaphor of the Mediterranean as a “liquid road”)
- Fontana (artist whose work is used as a metaphor for geography)
- Mention of historical figures such as Farinelli and De Matteis in passing.
Overall, the webinar advocates for a transformative approach to geography education that moves beyond memorization to foster passion, critical thinking, systemic understanding, and emotional engagement with the world.
Category
Educational
