Summary of "Minsan lang sila bata"

Overview

This is a photojournal documentary about child labor in several parts of the Philippines. A veteran photographer-narrator (who usually shoots celebrities) recounts an assignment documenting children working in dangerous, exploitative conditions in Cebu slaughterhouses, sugarcane haciendas in the provinces, and port unloading in Pulawan/Dapitan. The film mixes on-the-ground scenes, interviews with children, and reflection on the social causes and consequences of child labor.

Main reports and scenes

Cebu slaughterhouse

Night shifts at a “modern” slaughterhouse where pigs are electrocuted, scalded and skinned. Children work sharpening scissors, shaving remaining hair from carcasses and cutting off bits of fat or meat — often unpaid or paid only scraps. Conditions are filthy, noisy and hazardous (hot water, sharp steel, risk of slipping and cuts).

Examples: - Tikboy, about 9, works all night and receives no formal pay — only occasional small portions of fat or meat when the boss allows it. - Dio, about 14, works the night shift, later sells roughly 3 kilos of fat for about ₱7; he sleeps during the day and has effectively stopped schooling.

Hacienda / sugarcane fields (Ormoc, Negros and similar areas)

Children as young as 1–15 work as “hornals” cutting grass, carrying loads and harvesting sugarcane with machetes. Families often move from hacienda to hacienda.

Key problems: - Very low pay (examples cited: Delena reportedly earns ₱6/day; Sito’s family as little as ₱4/day in one instance). - Debt bondage: families borrow rice and supplies from landowners and remain perpetually indebted by harvest repayments. - Poor housing (no water, no toilets), malnutrition and stunted growth; school dropout as work gradually replaces education. - Physical danger from machetes and sharp tools and pressure from foremen.

Port / cement unloading (Pulawan / Dapitan)

Children are found unloading 40-kg sacks of cement from ship holds — confined, dusty, low-ventilation spaces that threaten respiratory health. They form heavy carry-and-pass lines under adult supervision; adults sometimes give children the hardest or most dangerous tasks because children are obedient and won’t protest.

Conditions and coping: - Pay is very low (one account: a two-day haul yields a little over ₱100 for a child). - Food and breaks are controlled by foremen. - Unhealthy coping practices (e.g., drinking tuba) are presented as protection against lung disease.

Analysis, arguments and conclusions

The documentary argues child labor is widespread across sectors — slaughterhouses, plantations and ports — and is rooted in poverty, indebtedness and employer practices that exploit children’s cheap, compliant labor.
Child labor deprives children of schooling, play and normal childhood development; malnutrition and hard work stunt growth and limit future opportunities.
Responsibility is shared: employers and landowners who hire children, parents who rely on children’s income, and the state (which should provide free education and protection) all bear responsibility.
The narrator urges journalists, citizens and photographers to care, document and advocate.
Education is presented as the primary route out of exploitation; several children express hopes for the future, underscoring the lost potential if they remain in labor.

“I want to become a lawyer to solve problems.” — Bobby

Tone and method

Intimate and empathetic: the photographer inserts personal reactions and moral questions about distance and responsibility.
Humanizing approach: portraits and on-site reporting show children and conditions firsthand rather than relying only on statistics.